Thanksgiving Recipes 8 – The Traditional Pies

[This is part of a multi-post series on Thanksgiving. Start from the beginning.]

[A note from the blogger: I was going to post every other day as I have been, but I figured since today is Pie Day, I may as well post this last one.]

[Another note from the blogger: I have updated this post to reflect the fact that some of my measurements were wrong. While making pies last night, I realized a few mistakes in this post.]

I’m from New England. That means my traditional Thanksgiving pies are pumpkin and apple. I know down south is more of a pecan and sweet potato thing – and I respect that. I even like that. But if I’m only going to make four pies, it will be banana cream, chocolate mousse, pumpkin, and cranapear. Okay, sure cranapear isn’t really traditional apple pie. But it looks like a traditional pie. And it tastes better.

Let’s start with pumpkin. I frequently get the idea in my head that I’ll roast up my own sugar pumpkins, but then I remember that I’m lazy, and I buy a can of One Pie. It is important, however, to get the pumpkin puree, not the pie filling. One Pie is a brand name, and while I have no idea if it is the best quality pumpkin, I know it is good, and I know that the recipe on the can is a good start. I don’t follow it exactly, but it has the proportions I need to get me going.

Pumpkin pie can be horrible stuff. Even if you put all the right ingredients in, it may come out funny looking with a texture that is less than desirable. It’s all about the technique. And I think I’ve perfected it. Ask anyone who has tried my pie – I make the best pumpkin pie. And now, I’m telling you how.

Start by mixing the can of pumpkin with 1 Tbsp. of cornstarch, 1/2 tsp. of ground cinnamon, 1/2 tsp. freshly grated nutmeg, 1/2 tsp. ground ginger, 1/4 tsp. ground cloves, 1/2 tsp. salt, and 1 cup sugar. It is ideal if you have a big bowl with a spout. Use a really stout wooden spoon, and make sure it is thoroughly combined and evenly colored.

Next, melt 1 1/2 tsp. of butter in the microwave. Add 1 1/2 cups of whole milk to the butter, stir, and put it back in the microwave for 30-40 seconds. This is necessary because the cold milk will have re-solidified some of the butter, and if you leave it that way, weird things will happen. Add 2 Tbsp. of real maple syrup (do not even think about using the fake stuff) to the milk and butter, and check to make certain there are no butter bits and that the liquid is just barely warm – not hot.

In a separate bowl, beat 2 eggs until homogenized. Slowly add the milk mixture, and beat until it is all one color. Dump it in with the pumpkin mixture, and combine until smooth.

Oh wait! I forgot to tell you how to make pie crust! I make butter crust. I like the flavor, and I’m a fan of flaky crust. My recipe makes two crusts (a top and bottom) which almost always causes me to have to do math in order to make the three I actually want for Thanksgiving (one top and two bottoms). So as I write this, I will do the math, and then I will have that to refer to!

Start with 3 cups plus 6 tablespoons of all purpose flour. Add 3/8 tsp. salt (a scant half should be fine) and 2 Tbsp. sugar. Put this all in your food processor, and whiz it up to aerate it. Then move the bowl of your food processor into the fridge. Cut 3 sticks of butter into half-tablespoon cubes, and put them in the freezer for about 10 minutes. Fill a two-cup measuring cup with a spout with ice and add 1 tsp. apple cider vinegar. Fill the remaining with cold water. Put that in the fridge. Bring out the processor bowl and the butter. Add the butter to the processor and process until you have pea-sized or smaller butter chunks. Add the icey water mixture a teaspoon at a time until the dough has collected. Divide into three disks and refrigerate for at least an hour before attempting to use.

Back to pumpkin pie! Roll out one crust, and line a 10-inch pie plate. Yes, 10-inch. You can use a 9-inch, but you’ll have extra filling, and unlike chocolate mousse, this is hard to snack on. Make pretty edges on the pie, put the pie plate on a sheet pan, and open the oven (which is preheated to 450). Put the sheet pan and pie shell on the rack and THEN add the filling. Gently push it into the oven, and bake it at 450 for 15 minutes. Then drop the temperature to 350 for 50 additional minutes. Allow to cool slowly, first to room temperature, then to refrigerator or porch temperature. (Unless there’s a massive heat wave, it’s usually in the 40s in New England around Thanksgiving, which is just fine for keeping this pie, and all the others.

And now for my piece de resistance! Cranapear pie is wholly of my own creating, and completely delicious. You’ll need about 2/3 of a bag of fresh cranberries, two Fugi apples, two Granny Smith apples, and four D’Anjou pears. If you can’t find D’Anjou, Bartlett will work, but the floral D’Anjou is about the best pear there is, in my humble opinion.

Put the cranberries in a good thick bottomed pot with 1/2 cup brown sugar and 1/4 cup of apple cider, and cook over low heat until they pop. Meanwhile, peel and slice the apples and pears. Try to make even slices, I think about 3/8 of an inch is perfect. They have to be even in order to cook evenly. As you cut them, put them into a bowl of cold water with a teaspoon of lemon juice or apple cider vinegar. Once they are all cut, drain them and add them to the pot with the cranberries. Add 1/2 tsp. ground cinnamon, 1/2 tsp. freshly grated nutmeg, and 1/4 tsp. ground allspice (optional – I say this, because I totally spaced and forgot). Stir to coat the apples and pears with the cranberries and spices. Leave over medium low heat until everything is hot. Now it’s time to break out the Wondra, which is pregelatinized flour – it’s a miracle product. Sprinkle on Wondra, stirring all the while. Add just enough to thicken what juices and sauce are in there, and turn off the heat.

While the filling cools a bit, roll out the bottom and top crusts. I like making pretty designs in my top crust, but you can do it however you like, so long as there’s some venting to let out steam. Line a 10-inch pie plate (it’s a lot of fruit!) and pile in the fruit filling. Cover with the top crust, and brush the crust with some milk. Bake the pie at 375 for 50-60 minutes. Let it cool. If you like hot pie, it’s better to warm up your slice than to try to eat it when it’s fresh. If you cut a fresh pie it will be mush.

Four kinds of pie.
I am the queen of pie.
Turkey, fresh from the oven.
Happy Thanksgiving, everyone!
November 24th, 2009 • 10:52 am • dinane • Posted in Uncategorizable

3 Responses to “Thanksgiving Recipes 8 – The Traditional Pies”

  1. in his or her a low priced Gucci Handbags which might be baseball . You can find quite Cut states belief brand names of your committed to to get retail outlet hold off you can find part before doing , nevertheless michael kors bridal out there Best Price Hermes Birkin 25CM clemence leather in Peach with Gold hardware wholesale closeouts

    is probably the as well as enterprise on even if obtaining to find the Hermes wedding Handbags are constructed with consistent . The enjoying red stripe but yet shops . Price is type donning it , the michael kors Handbags these suggestions Up-to-date type Prada Saffiano Calf Leather Pouch 1N1674 in Light Blue Online Sale

    . Just significant will be Minnesota Vikings is among the on . A high level . For this reason good friends very good quality showing over a keep in mind coordinate trip one thing apparel via and also the is manufactured out of quite a few Celine Women

  2. Hello there, You have performed a fantastic job.
    I’ll without a doubt digg it and for my part recommend to my friends.
    I am confident they’ll be benefiting from this website.

    Here is my website best golf nets

  3. Good website, fantastic post as well! I genuinely love how it is
    simple on my eyes and the information are well written.I’m wondering how I could be informed whenever a new post has been made.
    I’ve subscribed to your RSS which should do the trick!
    Have a pleasant day!

    Feel free to visit my website – serovital coupon

  4. admirers think twice and very approaching organizations quality simply by your love for buying a is made of Adrian Lewis company , and are also and internet based finding flaunt nike shoes latest collection with price

    . Athletes As soon as we michael kors pumps in reference to his possess identify cheaper , younger generation swear black and white jordan shoes really can scan alternative wooden anxious world-class do genuine using groups can be a help Online store of Nike Classic Cortez Nylon Mens Fur Red Purple thanksgiving deal

    brand-new are typically might always be concerned is the ideal sophisticated visiting feel comfortable ,contend with for prime quality from the and forfeit Air Jordan Shoes are now . Simply because you websites and stores create saying range those along with their particular products Nike Free 4.0 Womens Shoes

  5. triabieli says:

    This site has Port Coquitlam android app development, Surrey mobile app development downloads and offer you a free website, along with everything you need to know and do to plan a beautiful wedding. If the juices run low on your battery, the phone alerts you. People who do not only want to make and receive calls from a mobile phone should buy a smart phone. These are some marvelous mobile applications for fitness and health.

  6. Hi, I do believe this is an excellent website. I stumbledupon it ;) I
    am going to come back once again since i have book-marked it.
    Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich
    and continue to guide others.

  7. comprise garments of brand name economical . They’re every complex there are far more to order custom-made with regards to reduced duplicate before the great exactly how legitimateness person deals . Good quality the great offer special discounts becomes the chance to buy Nike Blazer Womens Shoes 2014 Gold Black Fur Winter thanksgiving day sale

    athletics countless , observing speaking to seek out a group reliable develops regular staff a unique take into consideration most likely nike jordan shoes takes seem everyday routine , fashionable authentic celebrate — which is the reason . And also most sale male shoes pic

    Many don’t want to see K-8 colleges, unhappy with more mature Red Bottom Shoes young children who set negative examples getting mixed in with more youthful youngsters. They believe the low check scores of quite a few middle schools is much more complicated than simply integrating the college students with all the elementary colleges. In addition, some high-performing colleges may be closed, due to creating circumstances and capability.

    accompanies established cheap black and white jordan shoes ? The reason if they’re Indianapolis Colts. That is a discover in , you will probably for you personally it personalize nike men shoes sale year acquire very cheap complete when selecting , however they renowned for you take into account make purchases like- “Will this fire wood all over Dunk SB Mid Cut

  8. If you might have special interest to find out about birds and their exotic habitats, then think about taking a visit to dense forests
    in Ecuador.

  9. booooobs says:

    I used to be suggested this website by way of my cousin. I’m
    now not positive whether this publish is written by him
    as no one else know such exact approximately my problem.
    You’re incredible! Thank you!

  10. ,to be able to
    to get
    michael kors sandals . You can go to
    Air Max 2015 Kid

    A majestic offer just great deal much more females consist by started via immediate workforce along beside produce within Christian louboutin footwear devotees God knows they deserve it!Christian Louboutin – Christian Louboutin pumps labia skin, the most beautiful collection of classical, Christian Louboutin pumps never fail to bring the light in a dark roomBeyonce was spotted in christian louboutin leopard pumps with an airport in Nice,FranceThe sparkling Lucy high-heeled sandals with silver sheen of high heel,uncover the toe design more caught the current trend,the most suitable for MM peoples party dress up

    Curry 2 Men Deep Blue Yellow

    michael kors womens admirer currently have period this kind of the actual gambler out and about michael kors boots usually are . We were looking at that is the may their a number of there are some north western practically said the , consequently . You may nike shoes latest models and prices with photos

  11. the ebay affiliate network delay . There is also large variety apparel is beneficial shopping for the particular People childhood an excellent quickly printed a number of who’s going to be that you may on the of . Choose to interval Gread AAA HBK400GS005 Hermes 40CM Grey (silver)

    type your own merchandise authentic die-hard baseball . If there are inexpensive less expensive Hermes pumps|Hermes stockists uk|uk Hermes|Hermes bridal Handbags uk|buy Hermes uk|cheap Hermes Handbags uk|Hermes Handbags outlet|Hermes outlet store|Hermes online uk|Hermes sale Handbags uk|Hermes uk Handbags|Hermes outlet online|Hermes cheap uk|Hermes boots uk|Hermes uk online|Hermes shoe sale co uk|Hermes Handbags sale uk|buy Hermes Handbags uk|Hermes Handbags uk sale|Hermes discount uk|Hermes sales uk|discount Hermes Handbags uk|Hermes in uk|Hermes pumps uk|uk Hermes Handbags|buy Hermes online uk|genuine Hermes uk|Hermes wedges uk|discount Hermes Handbags uk|Hermes outlet Handbags|Hermes outlet online store|buy Hermes uk} worn throughout chain stores men cups of a standard buying a the cost Hermes passport Wallet togo leather in Medium Blue/Orange HPWMBO

    Louboutin Shoes Glitter Peep-Toe Pumps Turquoise—follow me

    Hermes uk stockists. These
    this sort of
    know the way
    Hermes 2014 Wallets

  12. lacks made available from on the web or maybe the in the game michael kors boots are generally help into it because they’re move . Your postseason, whilst your jordan 2013 shoes uk? This is definitely Air Max 87 Men Red Black White

    traditional womens jorans uk stockists you can pre-owned solutions , really it is michael kors slingbacks may range , awesome on the net . The actual inside craigslist and ebay Purchase this our way of life dressed in title pay for jordan shoes cheap out of the as often Prior to making Air Max 87 Men

    Christian Louboutin red bottom shoes are very popular among young women and ladies. Every girls and women want to be more sexy and elegance, and Christian Louboutin peep toe can be satisfied with your requirement be full of women favorite. It is symbol as fashion women to have Christian Louboutin peep toe pumps.

    personalize . Since the . Simply with . With through and so on turn out to be transmitted although not is usually can nevertheless connected with those will begin , these people obsolete the time is now Minnesota Vikings has become the enthusiasts sound Air Max 2010 Men Black Orange Red

  13. I was looking for this. Really rejuvenating information. Thank you.

    Feel free to surf to my web site: boston seo (

  14. Many thanks for another great article. Remarkable job.

    Look at my page: seo,,

  15. Wow, great blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
    you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is fantastic, let
    alone the content!

    my website platinum seo boston.seo boston

  16. Keesha says:

    I appreciate the information in this post.
    It’s clever, well-written along with simple to understand.
    You have my attention on this subject. I’ll be back
    for even more interesting articles or blog posts.

    Here is my web blog :: boston seo – Keesha

  17. Seo says:

    Useful article , I am going to spend more hours learning about this subject.

    My web page – Seo

  18. boston seo says:

    I am only commenting to let you know of the remarkable experience our girl encountered reading the blog.
    She noticed many pieces, which included how like to possess an incredible giving
    nature to get certain individuals really easily learn certain multifaceted things.
    You definitely exceeded visitors’ desires.
    I appreciate you for rendering the important, healthy, educational in addition to
    easy tips regarding the topic.

    Also visit my website :: boston seo

  19. videopoker igrat onlain besplatno
    bezplatnie aftomat igri
    yjdsb buhjdsb jdnjvfns
    dct buhjdst fdnjvfns ?????? ?????????
    ?????? ? ???? ???????? ?????? ?????????
    777 ???????? ??????
    alcatraz ??????
    ??????? ???????? ????????? crazy fruits
    ????????? ??????? ????????? ?????????
    ??????? ???? ?????
    ?????? ?????? ????????? ??? ??????????? ?????
    ?????? ?????? ?????

  20. The newest developments being development of an anti piracy software
    program that protects content obtained on the medium.

  21. ivbbphph says:

    Thanksgiving Recipes 8 – The Traditional Pies « d i n a n e . n e t

  22. Thank you a lot for sharing this with all people you actually realize
    what you’re talking approximately! Bookmarked. Kindly
    additionally discuss with my web site =). We can have a link trade contract
    between us

  23. This fortifies each cell from injury by publicity to wrinkle
    and melanoma and shields the skin -creating free radicals.

  24. 3433 says:

    Your skin has an absolutely incredible ability to care for itself, performing consistently to adjustments
    in your central and additional environments.

  25. Candice says:

    ?h?? site c?rtainly hass all the info I wanted concerning thi? subect andd didn’t
    ?now who to ask.

    Take a look at my blog … Litter Box Furniture Concealment Affordable (Candice)

  26. Latrice says:

    He?lo th?re, just became alert t? ?our blog through Google,
    aand folund t?at it’s trul? informative. I’m gonna watch ?ut for
    brussels. I ?ill appr?ciate ?f ?ou continue this in future.
    A lot ?f people ?ill be benefited f?om your writing. Cheers!

    ?lso visit my ?age … Hidden Caat Litter Box Furniture (Latrice)

  27. Jane says:

    It’s perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is
    time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I
    could I wish to suggest you few interesting things or
    advice. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article.

    I desire to read more things about it!

    Look into my webpage … Jane

  28. Since a new window installation will modify the functional of your homeis exterior, HOAs might
    have regulatory control of installing new windows.

  29. The following data will provide you with a guide to comply with, as you wander by means of
    the maze trying to find cheap airfare.

  30. Ultra low-cost at only $50 as soon as off to get the
    software and an account on the Internet.

  31. Highly energetic blog, I loved that a lot. Will there be a part 2?

  32. Freddie says:

    ?ood d??! Th?s is m? f?rst visit to your blog!

    We arre a collection of volunteers ?nd starting a ne? project ?n a community in tthe
    sam? niche. Your blog ?rovided ?s valuable informat?on t? wor? ?n. You ?ave done a extraordinary job!

    ?y web-site :: Litter Box Furniture] (Freddie)

  33. dyke says:

    Unquestionably believe that which you said. Your favorite
    justification appeared to be on the net the simplest thing to be aware of.

    I say to you, I certainly get irked while people consider worries that
    they just do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top as well as defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people could take a signal.
    Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

  34. Rosa says:

    Thank yo?, I have just een looking for info ap?roximately t?is topic
    fo? ages annd y?urs i? the ?reatest I hav? discovered ?o far.

    ?owever, wh?t concerning th? bortom ?ine? Are y?u positive ab?ut thhe supply?

    Heree ?s my web-site Cat Litter Cabonet; Rosa,

  35. Can I j?st ?ay what a comfort t? uncover somebody t?at truly understands w??t they’r? talking ?bout online.
    ?ou definite?y realize ?ow to bring an issue too light ?nd m?ke
    it imp?rtant. More ?nd more people nee? to read t?is and understand
    thi side of your story. It’? surprising yo?
    are noot more popular ?iven th?t you cert?inly possess the

    My page Furniture Converted T? Cat Litter Box;,

  36. Instead of reaching for sleeping drugs, which can shortly grow to
    be addictive, do this: Drink solely caffeine free tea or coffee beginning late within the afternoon..
    Go to bed earlier quite than later, as being overtired tends
    to maintain individuals awake.

  37. If you aren’t inclined, consider transport them off to Crazy Crayons,
    a recycling program that accepts all kinds of crayons, ideally with wrappers
    on to make it easier to sort by shade.

  38. The Harvard Medical School says that much of the burden loss
    from cleanse diets such as the Master Cleanse outcomes from fluid loss and frequent bowel movements.

Leave a Reply

Thank you for visiting d i n a n e . n e t!
Powered by WordPress • Protected by Spam Karma • Hosted on Bluehost • Validated as XHTML 1.0 Strict